Premium Italian Imports in NJ
At Nicholas Markets, our Italian Heritage is something we’ve held close to our hearts for 80+ years. That’s why each of our New Jersey stores are stocked with carefully selected Italian imports that reflect who we are, where we come from and where we’re headed.
Italy’s food standards are among the highest in the world, and uphold that standard in every item we carry. From traceable sourcing to outstanding flavor, our exclusive Italian imports are selected for their quality, value and taste so you can shop knowing that every Italian import purchased delivers the best Italy has to offer.
Whether you’re cooking from memory, or discovering a new ingredient for the first time, our expanding and exclusive selection of Italian imports makes it easy to shop and cook the Italian way. Explore it today
Why Our Italian Imports Stand Apart
Most grocery stores order imports from a catalog. We don’t. We source, taste, and build relationships with Italian producers who share our standards of quality and authenticity.
Quality and Depth
You Can Explore
At Nicholas Markets, we offer one of the largest and exclusively expanding selections of Italian imports in NJ. Our collection spans across a vast amount of regions and categories, so you’re guaranteed to find a favorite or something new that you won’t find elsewhere.
Italian Standards
We Stand Behind
For generations, Italy’s food standards have set the global benchmark—where quality, health, and taste are non-negotiable. We hold our imports to these same exacting standards at Nicholas Markets. The result? Premium ingredients, you can savor and share.
An Italian Experience,
Aisle by Aisle
Our Italian imports fill aisles, not just a few shelves. With an expanding collection, you’ll find that no matter where you step or turn, our Italian products are there greet you. Discover new favorites and fill your cart with rare finds.
Seasonal & Holiday Favorites
Italian traditions shine during the holidays. Shop seasonal imports like classic panettone, sweet torrone and Taralli’s for La Befana, and other festive specialties that are perfect for your holiday gathering.
Stock up early in-store or through the Fresh Grocer app to enjoy the season without the crowds.
Discover the Collection
Barrel Aged Balsamic Vinegars
Made in the Modena and Reggio Emilia parts of Italy, and aged from 1 to 25 years in wooden barrels, our exclusive balsamic vinegars deliver a deep and tangy flavor that is sure to elevate your next meal. Grab a bottle of it today.
Artisanal Pasta & Regional Grains
Grown, milled, and harvested in Italy, our 100% durum wheat semolina pastas from brands like Paolo’s, Flor, and Filotea offer rich flavor and perfect texture. We also carry carefully crafted gluten-free corn pastas with authentic taste. Explore our selection today.
Premium Olive Oils
Great Italian cooking starts with great olive oil. Our selection includes imported favorites like Guglielmi, Arte Olio and Paolo’s that are harvested, cold-pressed and extracted from different regions of Italy so you can taste the unique flavor profile in each drop you pour. Stop by and pick one up today.
Cheeses and Dairy
Italian meals are built on good cheese. Stop by our Cheese Shop to find imported favorites like Parmigiano Reggiano and Pecorino, along with fresh mozzarella that we craft in-house each day.
Sweets & Snacks
Italian sweets bring comfort to everyday moments. Discover familiar Italian favorites like Muliano Bianco cookies and San Carlo chips, or browse our bakery for Italian treats you can’t resist.
Find The Perfect Cut For Your Table!
Every product we sell holds a flavor and story behind it. Explore the map below to see where our imports originate from and shop our standout specialities today.
Nicholas Markets LOCATIONS
Serving Essex County since 1943, our Cedar Grove store brings our mission of fresh, high-quality, affordable foods to every aisle our shoppers walk through. Step inside, and you’ll find a curated mix of everyday essentials, artisanally specials, along with exclusive offerings like our freshly prepared sushi bar and smoked meats made in-store. Visit Nicholas Markets Cedar Grove today to experience the tradition and care that has made us Essex County’s trusted speciality grocer for decades.
Cedar Grove
597 Pompton Avenue,
Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone (973) 595 5080
Manager Ryan Mucks
Store Hours
Mon – Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Conveniently located in the heart of Middlesex County, our Colonia store brings together the everyday essentials you need with specialty departments that make grocery shopping enjoyable. Colonia is also home to our exclusive Saturday morning Bob Breakfasts, where our in-store chefs prepare hot, ready-to-enjoy breakfasts for our early morning Saturday shoppers. Stop in today to browse, taste, and discover something new.
Colonia
510 Inman Avenue,
Colonia, NJ 07067
Phone (732) 388 6363
Manager Doug Mercandino
Store Hours
Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Nestled in Bergen County, our North Haledon store stands as our central grocery hub that blends decades of family tradition with modern specialty grocery offerings. Since 1943, it has provided Haledon and neighboring communities, including Wayne and Paterson, with quality groceries, signature items, and exclusive offerings like our fresh sushi bar and Italian specialty hot bar. Come visit us today to experience the unique flavors that our flagship store has to offer.
North Haledon
1068 High Mountain Road,
North Haldon, NJ 07508
Phone (973) 595 5506
Manager Dave Secor
Store Hours
Mon-Sat: 7:00am – 10:00pm
Since 1943, our Township of Washington store has offered Passaic County locals with a grocery experience that combines quality, convenience, and flavor. While our curated departments and signature shops have long defined who we are, one of our exclusive offerings offered only at our Township of Washington location is our Donna’s Produce section where shoppers can find fresh, locally sourced vegetarian prepared meals. Experience and taste for yourself why Nicholas Market Township of Washington continues to remain North Jersey’s go-to specialty grocer.
Township of Washington
315 Pascack Road,
Washington Twp., NJ 07676
Phone (201) 666 2185
Manager Ed Greenwald
Store Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:00am – 10:00pm
Order Online Anytime
Our Italian imports are always within reach. Order through the Fresh Grocer app for delivery or curbside pickup today.
Contact Us
Learn About Italian Food
Italian imports are just one part of what shapes our stores. Explore our blog to learn how the products we carry and the recipes behind them continue to influence what you see on our shelves.
Experience The Flavors at Nicholas Markets! >
Whether you know these flavors well or are discovering them for the first time, our Italian imports are thoughtfully selected and intentionally displayed so you can find them no matter which aisle you’re in. Stop by one of our four locations and take your time exploring today