Full-Service Cheese Shop in NJ

At Nicholas Markets, we believe every cheese wheel, wedge, log, block, and crumble should tell a story—not just sit on a shelf. As a family-owned specialty grocery store serving North and Central Jersey, we’ve spent over 80 years curating selections that turn everyday meals into something memorable. From freshly made hand-stretched mozzarella to bold imports and local treasures, you’re sure to find a cheese that exceeds your expectations.

Your Go-To NJ Destination for Artisanal Cheese

Unlike the shrink-wrapped blocks and pre-sliced packages sold at most big box grocery stores, our cheeses are hand-selected by our team who takes the time to understand what you’re serving and who you’re feeding. Whether you’re planning a weeknight pasta or hosting a holiday gathering, we’re here to help you choose the perfect wedge and offer pairing tips that will elevate your next meal.

Looking to build the perfect charcuterie spread? Pair your cheese with hand-sliced meats and gourmet accompaniments from our delicatessen.

Fresh Mozzarella Made In House

When you’re looking for the finest mozzarella in New Jersey, our in-house selection sets the standard. Made fresh daily using techniques passed down through generations, each pillowy ball is skillfully crafted and sold with the understanding that exceptional taste doesn’t have to come at an exaggerated price. Have a question about pairing or preparation? Ask one of our cheese experts today.

From sandwiches and salads to homemade pastas and antipasto boards, you’ll find that our fresh mozzarella is the kind of cheese that delivers flavor with every bite.

Order Your Cheese of Choice Online

Can’t make it in? Order on the Fresh Grocer app and enjoy the same artisan cheeses our cheese shop is known for today.

Nicholas Markets LOCATIONS

When you step into a Nicholas Markets cheese shop, you’ll find more than a premium wedge of cheese. You’ll be greeted with generations of craftsmanship and a warmth that makes choosing cheese for your family feel less like a chore and more like a discovery. Visit one of our four New Jersey stores to experience the difference for yourself.

Serving Essex County since 1943, our Cedar Grove store brings our mission of fresh, high-quality, affordable foods to every aisle our shoppers walk through. Step inside, and you’ll find a curated mix of everyday essentials, artisanal specials, along with exclusive offerings like our freshly prepared sushi bar and smoked meats made in-store. Visit Nicholas Markets Cedar Grove today to experience the tradition and care that has made us Essex County’s trusted specialty grocer for decades.

Cedar Grove

597 Pompton Avenue,
Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone (973) 595 0655
Manager Ryan Mucks

Store Hours
Mon – Fri: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Sat-Sun: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Conveniently located in the heart of Middlesex County, our Colonia store brings together the everyday essentials you need with specialty departments that make grocery shopping enjoyable. Colonia is also home to our exclusive Saturday morning Bob Breakfasts, where our in-store chefs prepare hot, ready-to-enjoy breakfasts for our early morning Saturday shoppers. Stop in today to browse, taste, and discover something new.

Colonia

510 Inman Avenue,
Colonia, NJ 07067
Phone (732) 388 6363
Manager Doug Mercandino

Store Hours
Mon – Sat: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Sunday: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Nestled in Bergen County, our North Haledon store stands as our central grocery hub that blends decades of family tradition with modern specialty grocery offerings. Since 1943, it has provided Haledon and neighboring communities, including Wayne and Paterson, with quality groceries, signature items, and exclusive offerings like our fresh sushi bar and Italian specialty hot bar. Come visit us today to experience the unique flavors that our flagship store has to offer.

North Haledon

1068 High Mountain Road,
North Haledon, NJ 07508
Phone (973) 423 5506
Manager David Secor

Store Hours
Mon-Sat: 7:00am – 9:00pm

Sunday: 7:00am – 8:00pm

Since 1943, our Township of Washington store has offered Passaic County locals with a grocery experience that combines quality, convenience, and flavor. While our curated departments and signature shops have long defined who we are, one of our exclusive offerings offered only at our Township of Washington location is our Donna’s Produce section where shoppers can find fresh, locally sourced vegetarian prepared meals. Experience and taste for yourself why Nicholas Market Township of Washington continues to remain North Jersey’s go-to specialty grocer.

Township of Washington

315 Pascack Road, Township of
Washington, NJ 07676
Phone (201) 666 2185
Manager Ed Greenwald

Store Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:00am – 9:00pm

Frequently Asked Questions

Where does Nicholas Markets source its cheese?

Cheese is at the heart of our Italian roots. Our cheese shop experts hand-select artisanal cheeses from trusted New Jersey producers, alongside imported favorites from Italy, France, and beyond. We also make our own fresh mozzarella in-house every day, using the same time-honored techniques that have been part of our family tradition for generations. Try a slice or a ball of fresh mozzarella, at any one of our four New Jersey locations.

Do you make mozzarella fresh in-store?

Yes. At any of our four New Jersey locations, you’ll find our team hand-stretching fresh mozzarella daily, so what you take home is a soft, pillowy ball of cheese, not a shrink-wrapped block from a warehouse.

Can I get help building a cheese or charcuterie board?

Absolutely, that’s what our cheese shop experts are here for. Tell them the occasion, whether it’s a holiday spread, a party platter, or just a Tuesday-night treat. They’ll help you choose the right pairings and portions, and can even suggest meats from our delicatessen to round out the board.

Can I order cheese online for pickup or delivery?

Yes, your favorite cheeses can be ordered through the Fresh Grocer app for pickup or delivered through DoorDash, Instacart, or Uber Eats, so you can enjoy the same artisan selection without a trip to the counter.

Which Nicholas Markets locations have a full-service cheese shop?

Each of our four New Jersey locations is home to a full-service cheese shop, staffed by team members who genuinely know their cheese and love helping customers find exactly what they need.

Cheese Shop