Bakery

Full-Service Bakery Shop in NJ

At Nicholas Markets, our bakery isn’t just another department, it’s a signature store where generations of craft and family recipes come to life every single day. For over 80 years, our New Jersey bakery has been the place where skilled pastry chefs create bread, cakes, and pastries that bring families together and make moments sweeter. While it may be easy to settle for mass-produced baked goods, we believe you deserve fresh-baked quality that turns a simple purchase into something worth savoring. Visit one of our bakery locations in North or Central Jersey and experience the difference for yourself.

ORDER TODAY

Our Bakery Specials Bakery

Artisan Baked Breads

Every loaf that leaves our ovens is shaped by hand, baked with intention, and made using ingredients you can trust. From Italian semolina and hearty multigrain to freshly baked gluten-free varieties, our artisan breads are never rushed, never mass-produced, and always worth the trip.

Order Now

Custom Cakes

At Nicholas Markets, our custom cakes are freshly handcrafted and designed around your story, your colors, and your sweetest ideas. Whether you're planning a wedding, a birthday, or another milestone event, our pastry chefs bring your vision to life with premium ingredients and artistic detail that sets us apart.
Planning something bigger? Explore our full catering services to complete your celebration.

Order Now

Italian Pastries

At Nicholas Markets, our hand-selected pastry chefs bring generations of Italian tradition to life every single day. From delicate, flaky sfogliatelle to rich, layered tiramisu and golden cannoli filled to order, each pastry we serve is a testament to our Italian roots. Made fresh daily using authentic recipes and the finest imported ingredients, our treats are baked so you can savor the moment, and maybe grab an extra box for tomorrow.

Order Now

Classic Pastries

Some treats never go out of style, and our classic pastries prove exactly why. From buttery croissants that shatter at first bite to our legendary jelly rolls that have North Jersey neighborhoods talking, you're sure to find a treat that matches your sweet tooth.

Order Now

Order Online on The Fresh Grocer App

Can’t stop by today? Order online through Instacart Order on the Fresh Grocer app and have our fresh-baked breads, pastries, or desserts delivered right to your door.

ORDER ONLINE

Nicholas Markets LOCATIONS

At Nicholas Markets Bakery, every bite reminds you what real, homemade flavor tastes like. Stop by one of our NJ Bakeries and see why generations of families have trusted us to make their moments sweeter.

Serving Essex County since 1943, our Cedar Grove store brings our mission of fresh, high-quality, affordable foods to every aisle our shoppers walk through. Step inside, and you’ll find a curated mix of everyday essentials, artisanal specials, along with exclusive offerings like our freshly prepared sushi bar and smoked meats made in-store. Visit Nicholas Markets Cedar Grove today to experience the tradition and care that has made us Essex County’s trusted speciality grocer for decades.
Cedar Grove

597 Pompton Avenue,
Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone (973) 595 5080
Manager Ryan Mucks

Store Hours
Mon – Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Conveniently located in the heart of Middlesex County, our Colonia store brings together the everyday essentials you need with specialty departments that make grocery shopping enjoyable. Colonia is also home to our exclusive Saturday morning Bob Breakfasts, where our in-store chefs prepare hot, ready-to-enjoy breakfasts for our early morning Saturday shoppers. Stop in today to browse, taste, and discover something new.
Colonia

510 Inman Avenue,
Colonia, NJ 07067
Phone (732) 388 6363
Manager Doug Mercandino

Store Hours
Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Nestled in Bergen County, our North Haledon store stands as our central grocery hub that blends decades of family tradition with modern specialty grocery offerings. Since 1943, it has provided Haledon and neighboring communities, including Wayne and Paterson, with quality groceries, signature items, and exclusive offerings like our fresh sushi bar and Italian specialty hot bar. Come visit us today to experience the unique flavors that our flagship store has to offer.

North Haledon

1068 High Mountain Road,
North Haldon, NJ 07508
Phone (973) 595 5506
Manager Dave Secor

Store Hours
Mon-Sat: 7:00am – 10:00pm

Since 1943, our Township of Washington store has offered Passaic County locals with a grocery experience that combines quality, convenience, and flavor. While our curated departments and signature shops have long defined who we are, one of our exclusive offerings offered only at our Township of Washington location is our Donna’s Produce section where shoppers can find fresh, locally sourced vegetarian prepared meals. Experience and taste for yourself why Nicholas Market Township of Washington continues to remain North Jersey’s go-to specialty grocer.

Township of Washington

315 Pascack Road,
Washington Twp., NJ 07676
Phone (201) 666 2185
Manager Ed Greenwald

Store Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:00am – 10:00pm

Contact Us