Healthy Options - Curated Health-Conscious Items
Coming Soon To Nicholas Markets
When the Maniaci family opened their first Nicholas Markets, they made a promise: to source the best ingredients and never compromise on quality. That same promise shapes every decision we make today and is the foundation of our Nick’s Picks.
Setting a New Bar for Simple, Nutritious, and Flavorful Choices
At Nicholas Markets, we choose to set the bar high and offer you nothing less than what you deserve. That is why each Nick’s Picks item will be evaluated by our wellness team using criteria that prioritizes clean ingredients, responsible sourcing, and a high nutritional value.
What sets Nicholas Markets apart:
- No seed oils: We choose olive, avocado, and coconut oils that support your long-term wellness instead of highly processed alternatives
- Family-tested selections: Every product must be something we’d confidently serve to our own families
- Transparency over trends: If it doesn’t meet our standards, it doesn’t make the cut—regardless of what’s popular
- 80+ years of trust: The same family values that built our departments and signature stores now guide our grocery curation
Unlike other well known grocery stores that stock whatever sells, we’re building Nick’s Picks around a simple question: Would we feed this to someone we love?
Frequently Asked Questions FAQ's
How are Nick’s Picks products chosen?
Each item is reviewed against our in-house wellness standards, focusing on clean ingredients, responsible sourcing, and nutritional balance. Only products that meet our health criteria make it to the shelf.
Why does Nicholas Markets avoid seed oils in Nick’s Picks?
Seed oils undergo heavy processing that compromises nutritional value. We choose olive, avocado, and coconut oils that offer cleaner, more natural nutrition supporting your long-term wellness.
Are Nick’s Picks items more expensive than regular grocery products?
No, you’ll find that our Nick’s Picks items are comparable to our other items found in all of our stores.
Do Nick’s Picks products change seasonally?
Yes, our team does update our product seasonally but some will be available all year round too.
Are Nick’s Picks products available at every Nicholas Markets location?
Yes, no matter which Nicholas Markets you visit, you’ll find that all of our Nick’s Picks items listed can be found at one of each of our locations.
How do I know if something in-store is part of Nick’s Picks?
To know if something in-store is a part of our Nick Pick’s, be sure to look for a Nick’s Pick sticker. Our team diligently adds and updates these stickers so you can easily spot them. If you don’t see a sticker, we’ve also modified certain departments to have their own Nick’s Picks section so these items can be easily found.
Does Nick’s Picks offer products suitable for kids?
Definitely! We focus on foods that are both nutritious and family-friendly — easy to enjoy, easy to trust, and free from unnecessary additives.
Can I suggest a brand or product to be added to Nick’s Picks?
Absolutely, we welcome suggestions! Share your ideas with our team in-store or online — we’re always exploring new ways to expand our health-conscious lineup.
Find Nick's Picks at Your Local Nicholas Markets
When you visit a Nicholas Markets location, you’ll find more than exceptional groceries. You’ll discover a team and specialty grocer that remembers your preferences, answers your questions, and genuinely cares about helping you make choices that support you and your family’s wellness. From farm-fresh produce to artisan baked goods, every department reflects our commitment to providing you with unwavering quality.
Stop by one of our stores in North or Central Jersey to experience the Nicholas Markets difference firsthand.
Nicholas Markets LOCATIONS
Cedar Grove
597 Pompton Avenue,
Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone (973) 595 5080
Manager Ryan Mucks
Store Hours
Mon – Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Conveniently located in the heart of Middlesex County, our Colonia store brings together the everyday essentials you need with specialty departments that make grocery shopping enjoyable. Colonia is also home to our exclusive Saturday morning Bob Breakfasts, where our in-store chefs prepare hot, ready-to-enjoy breakfasts for our early morning Saturday shoppers. Stop in today to browse, taste, and discover something new.
Colonia
510 Inman Avenue,
Colonia, NJ 07067
Phone (732) 388 6363
Manager Doug Mercandino
Store Hours
Sun: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Nestled in Bergen County, our North Haledon store stands as our central grocery hub that blends decades of family tradition with modern specialty grocery offerings. Since 1943, it has provided Haledon and neighboring communities, including Wayne and Paterson, with quality groceries, signature items, and exclusive offerings like our fresh sushi bar and Italian specialty hot bar. Come visit us today to experience the unique flavors that our flagship store has to offer.
North Haledon
1068 High Mountain Road,
North Haldon, NJ 07508
Phone (973) 595 5506
Manager Dave Secor
Store Hours
Mon-Sat: 7:00am – 10:00pm
Since 1943, our Township of Washington store has offered Passaic County locals with a grocery experience that combines quality, convenience, and flavor. While our curated departments and signature shops have long defined who we are, one of our exclusive offerings found only at our Township of Washington location is our Donna’s Produce section where shoppers can find fresh, locally sourced vegetarian prepared meals. Experience and taste for yourself why Nicholas Market Township of Washington continues to remain North Jersey’s go-to specialty grocer.
Township of Washington
315 Pascack Road,
Washington Twp., NJ 07676
Phone (201) 666 2185
Manager Ed Greenwald
Store Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:00am – 10:00pm